Florida Schools Try to Adapt to New Rules on Gender, Bathrooms and Pronouns (2024)

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Supported by

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

As schools start, it’s been more paperwork, a culling of reading lists, as well as new regulations about bathrooms.

  • 361

Florida Schools Try to Adapt to New Rules on Gender, Bathrooms and Pronouns (1)

By Dana Goldstein

As a new school year begins in Florida this week, parents are filling out a flurry of new forms — specifying a student’s nickname or new name; allowing a child to check certain books out of the library; and opting in or out of health services ranging from counseling to temperature checks, calamine lotion and ice packs.

The new bureaucracy is an offshoot of Gov. Ron DeSantis’s increasingly muscular push for “parental rights” in education, with new laws and regulations that broadly restrict classroom instruction on gender and sexuality, including in high school, and prevent transgender students and staff members from using group bathrooms that match their gender identity.

Teachers will also be barred from asking students for their preferred pronouns and could lose their professional certification for violating the new laws. Course lists and classroom libraries are also under the microscope, with districts seeking to excise material that touches on gender and sexuality, including in classics like “Romeo and Juliet.”

Here is how some Florida school districts are interpreting the new laws.

They Have a Form for That

The new regulations have created a bureaucratic tangle, with several counties sending parents forms that must be filled out if they want their child referred to by something other than their legal name.

In Orange County, in and around Orlando, the district told parents that they must fill out the form even if “Robert” wishes to be called “Rob” — or if a trans child now goes by “Roberta.”

But school staff members “may elect” not to use she/her pronouns when referring to Roberta, according to the school district’s attorney, John C. Palmerini. In a memo to district staff, he cited House Bill 1069, a law signed by Governor DeSantis in May, which defines “sex” as corresponding to “external genitalia present at birth,” and also broadly restricts instruction on gender and sexuality.

Mr. Palmerini acknowledged in the memo that there was confusion about whether staff members could use a transgender student’s preferred pronouns after a request by that student’s parent. “The State Board of Education has not given guidance on this precise question,” he wrote, but he urged caution — suggesting teachers concerned about liability avoid the issue by referring to students by their last names.

But Carlos Guillermo Smith, a senior policy adviser for Equality Florida, an L.G.B.T.Q. rights group, said, “The districts are being put in a terrible position.” The sweeping restrictions, he said, are “the inevitable result of vague and bigoted legislation.”

In Palm Beach County, Michael Woods, a special-education teacher, said he was told in a faculty training session on Wednesday that when referring to transgender colleagues, he should use the title “teacher” instead of their preferred honorific such as Mr. or Ms., if that honorific does not match their sex assigned at birth.

He was also told that he should not refer to transgender students by their preferred names unless he was certain a parent had returned a permission slip. He knew of one specific transgender student, he said, whose parents would be unlikely to do so because of religious objections.

“It stifles conversation,” Mr. Woods said of the new law. “It stifles the relationship you built with that young person.”

Palm Beach County schools did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

New Bathroom Rules

The new state regulations around bathroom use in schools are clearer. Students, staff members and visitors will be required to use either the bathroom corresponding to the sex they were assigned at birth, or use a single-stall restroom. Districts that violate this law can be fined up to $10,000.

Mr. Woods said the rule could essentially out transgender students or staff members against their will, since they might be observed visiting only the single-stall bathroom, or asking where it is.

Literature Under Scrutiny

In Lee County, on the Gulf Coast, parents will receive a new “media access form.”

They can allow their children unrestricted access to library books; prevent any access; or allow their children access to books except those that have been challenged and reviewed for objectionable material — even if the review found the book was not objectionable.

Under Florida law, members of the public can challenge any school library book, a process that has often been used to object to works that center on the L.G.B.T.Q. experience, or on concepts such a structural racism.

The Lee County school district did not respond to a request for comment. But Christy DeVigili of the Florida Citizens Alliance, a conservative group that supports the new education regulations, said she welcomed the new permission forms, even if left-leaning activists could use the same process to dispute books she might approve of.

“That is the beauty of democracy,” she said. “There is nothing stopping any parent from any side of the coin from challenging any book in any library.”

The overall goal, she said, was to give parents “the ultimate decision-making authority, which is really what the law is designed for.”

A separate regulation now requires that a state-certified media specialist reviews individual classroom libraries to ensure that no book contains banned content, such as depictions of “sexual conduct.”

That has led to some confusion. Hillsborough County, in Tampa, initially told educators that meant they could assign excerpts from “Romeo and Juliet” but not the full play, which implies that the teen lovers consummate their romance.

But that guidance, while potentially in line with the law, seemed to buck state policymakers’ intentions. On Tuesday, the state education commissioner, Manny Diaz, Jr., named “Romeo and Juliet” a “book of the month” for August, alongside “Up From Slavery” by Booker T. Washington.

On Wednesday, Hillsborough interim superintendent Van Ayres sent a letter to the community acknowledging that the Shakespeare guidance had “unfortunately created some confusion.”

“To be clear, we are teaching Shakespeare in a variety of ways in high schools, everything from short excerpts to full novel readings,” he wrote.

Courses Under Fire

The broad restrictions on instruction about gender and sexuality have threatened a number of courses, including Advanced Placement Psychology. The College Board, which runs the A.P. program, advised Florida districts not to offer the class, saying the banned material was central to the discipline and Florida students who took the class might not qualify for college credit.

On Aug. 4, Mr. Diaz told superintendents that he believed the class could still be taught “in its entirety,” and the College Board walked back its previous statements.

But given the conflicting guidance, districts are scrambling to figure out whether they should stick with the popular class or seek out alternatives.

The Florida Department of Education did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

There is also the matter of sex education. Previously, local districts had some discretion on how it was taught, though the state required an emphasis on abstinence. Now, the state is asserting the power to approve of all curriculum materials, and requiring that students be taught that the male and female reproductive roles are “binary, stable and unchangeable.”

Dana Goldstein is a national correspondent for The Times, writing about family policy and demographics. She is the author of the bestselling “The Teacher Wars: A History of America’s Most Embattled Profession.” More about Dana Goldstein

A version of this article appears in print on , Section

A

, Page

10

of the New York edition

with the headline:

Florida Schools Hustle To Adapt to New Rules On Gender and More. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper | Subscribe

361

  • 361

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Florida Schools Try to Adapt to New Rules on Gender, Bathrooms and Pronouns (2024)

FAQs

Florida Schools Try to Adapt to New Rules on Gender, Bathrooms and Pronouns? ›

The new state regulations around bathroom use in schools are clearer. Students, staff members and visitors will be required to use either the bathroom corresponding to the sex they were assigned at birth, or use a single-stall restroom. Districts that violate this law can be fined up to $10,000.

Do Florida schools teach gender? ›

The revised rule came after Gov. Ron DeSantis and lawmakers this spring approved a law that prohibits instruction about sexual orientation and gender identity in pre-kindergarten through eighth grade. Previously such instruction was barred in kindergarten through third grade.

What is the nickname policy in Florida? ›

Under a new rule issued by the Florida Board of Education in July, parents must give consent for schools to call their child by a nickname, or any “deviation from the child's legal name.” The rule, according to a Board presentation, will “strengthen the rights of parents and safeguard their child's educational record ...

What is the new phone rule in Florida schools? ›

Simply put, students should not be using phones (or other wireless devices) while classroom instruction is taking place. At this time students are still allowed to keep their phones with their other belongings, but they should not use their phones during instructional time unless the teacher grants permission.

What are gender neutral pronouns in education? ›

Substitute gendered language for more inclusive language, such as “everybody,” “folks,” or “this person.” When in doubt about what pronouns someone uses, use the student's name and/or gender neutral pronoun “they/them”. Apologize when you make a mistake and misgender someone.

Can teachers use preferred pronouns in Florida? ›

Florida district bars trans teachers from using preferred pronouns and bathrooms to comply with state law. Orange County Public Schools issued the guidance Monday to follow two state laws affecting gender identity and bathroom usage in public schools, which took effect in July.

What is the new law in Florida about school? ›

In 2022, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, now a Republican presidential candidate, signed into law legislation that restricted public school instruction on topics of race, gender identity, and sexual orientation.

Can I legally go by my nickname? ›

If you want to change your legal name, you need to use a legal process. You are free to use an alias or a nickname at any time, but that is not your legal name. The reason for your name change will dictate which legal process you need to follow.

What do Florida residents call themselves? ›

The sunshine state is home to a population of Floridians.

Do students need permission to use nicknames in Florida? ›

Florida will now require parents consent first. If your child prefers going by a nickname, get ready to be greeted by a new form this school year. Florida students will need parental permission to go by anything other than their legal name due to recent legislation signed by Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis.

Can schools check your phone Florida? ›

Yet, school officials in Florida are permitted to confiscate and search the phone without notifying the parent if reasonable suspicion exists that the student possesses prohibited or illegally possessed items.

Why did Florida ban phones in school? ›

The law will take effect in July. Saying that social media does “more harm than good,” Gov. Ron DeSantis on Tuesday signed education changes that include prohibiting students from using cell phones during class time and curtailing use of the social-media platform TikTok on school grounds.

Is it illegal to have your phone out in school in Florida? ›

A student may possess a wireless communications device while the student is on school property or in attendance at a school function; however, a student may not use a wireless communications device during instructional time, except when expressly directed by a teacher solely for educational purposes.

What are the 7 gender pronouns? ›

Gendered pronouns include she and he, her and him, hers and his, and herself and himself. "Personal gender pronouns" (or PGPs) are the pronouns that people ask others to use in reference to themselves. They may be plural gender-neutral pronouns such as they, them, their(s).

What are the 4 gender pronouns? ›

Pronoun Table
SubjectiveObjectiveExamples
SheHerShe is studying. I studied with her. The book is hers.
HeHimHe is studying. I studied with him. The book is his.
TheyThemThey are studying. I studied with them. The book is theirs.
NameNameAlex is studying. I studied with Alex. The book is Alex's.
1 more row

Why are gender pronouns so controversial? ›

When it comes to pronouns to identify a person, we get into identity and that's where things get complex – and, often political. The big thing personal pronouns often signal is someone's gender identity. According to scientists, gender isn't a rigid he/she binary rooted in the sex a person was assigned at birth.

Do schools treat girls the same as boys? ›

The Bottom Line on Gender Inequality and Schools

Consciously or unconsciously, today's teachers treat boys and girls differently in classrooms. Boys are given more opportunities than girls. Disparities in gender influence the development of children, and this negative impact continues to grow with the children.

Is there gender equality in schools? ›

Gender equality is a global priority at UNESCO. While much progress has been made, large gender gaps still exist in education in many settings, most often at the expense of girls, although in some regions boys are at a disadvantage. Globally, 118.5 million girls and 125.5 million boys are out of school.

Are boys and girls equal in school? ›

The education gender gap emerges well before college, however: girls are more likely to graduate high school on time and perform substantially better on standardized reading tests than boys (and about as well in math). In this piece, we dive into how these gaps differ — or stay the same — across the U.S.

Is there gender discrimination in schools? ›

Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972: It is illegal for a school, university, or school district to discriminate against you based on your sex, race, color, religion, or national origin.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 5829

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Birthday: 1996-12-09

Address: Apt. 141 1406 Mitch Summit, New Teganshire, UT 82655-0699

Phone: +2296092334654

Job: Technology Architect

Hobby: Snowboarding, Scouting, Foreign language learning, Dowsing, Baton twirling, Sculpting, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Francesca Jacobs Ret, I am a innocent, super, beautiful, charming, lucky, gentle, clever person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.